8.7 Reasoning

As described at the start of this Chapter, the follow-up questions for each behavior include asking about the influencer and about the reason for doing or not doing the behavior. We have just analyzed the influencer data and here we consider the data about reasons.

The ‘reasons’ data is much more varied. Unlike the responses for influencers, the options for the questions about reasoning vary from question to question. The way we have used the reason data thus far is with targeted queries. For instance, in Table (8.8), one can subset the reasons provided based on the behavior of interest or if the answer was ‘yes’ or ‘no.’ One can search this table to see which reasons were commonly associated with each behavior, subset by the response of having done the recommended behavior (Qvalue = 1) or having not done it (Qvalue = 0).

This can be handy for contrasting the kinds of reasoning associated with doing or not doing a behavior.

Table 8.8: Searchable table of reasons for each behavior and influencer

Qnames
Qvalue
Reason
count
Chhathi
0
Chhathi rituals can be harmful for the newborn
103
Chhathi
0
Child is less than 6 days
1
Chhathi
0
Donìt know
5
Chhathi
0
I didnìt do the same in the previous delivery
170
Chhathi
0
I donìt believe in celebrating chhathi
244
Chhathi
0
Neighbors/relatives also donìt do
76
Chhathi
0
Nobody does in the family
234
Chhathi
0
Others
126
Chhathi
0
To ensure more care to the mother and newborn
8
Chhathi
0
To reduce stress on the newborn and mother
3
Chhathi
1
Better for the health of the
26
Chhathi
1
Donìt know
22
Chhathi
1
Everybody does in the family
875
Chhathi
1
For better future and health of the newborn
134
Chhathi
1
For godìs blessings
117
Chhathi
1
I believe in celebrating chhathi
878
Chhathi
1
I did the same in the previous delivery
640
Chhathi
1
Neighbors/relatives also do
785
Chhathi
1
Others
359
Chhathi
1
Reduces risk of evil eye
95
Mom_NB_Isolation
0
Donìt believe in child kept separately in isolation
165
Mom_NB_Isolation
0
Donìt believe in untouchability
82
Mom_NB_Isolation
0
Donìt know
8
Mom_NB_Isolation
0
I didnìt do the same in the previous delivery
118
Mom_NB_Isolation
0
Lack of space
115
1–25 of 486 rows
Show
...

In order to have an analysis that is more parallel in fashion to the influencer analysis above, and to aid in finding emergent patterns in the types of reasoning used, we also coded the responses into a common set of general types of reasoning.

The categories used were:
x
Biomedical reasoning
Cultural reasoning
General wellbeing
General wellbeing
Inconclusive reasoning
Normative: community
Normative: family
Other
Personal experience
Private healthcare
Resources: human
Resources: information
Resources: monetary
Resources: time
Self confidence
Service and access

An overview of this coding is in the following table:

The following three heatmaps show the