8.1 Quick revision

We strongly recommend trying these Quick revision questions before your tutorial.

Researchers studied the impact of a gluten-free diet on dental cavities (Khalaf et al. 2020). Some of the summary information regarding the number decayed, missing and filled teeth (DMFT) is shown below.

Diet	Sample size	Mean	Standard deviation	Standard error
Coeliac	23	8.39	4.4	0.92
Non-coeliac	23	8.17	4.1	0.86
Difference		0.22		1.3

An exact \(95\)% CI is given as for the difference is \(-2.32\) to \(2.76\).

Using the \(68\)--\(95\)--\(99.7\) rule gives a slightly different CI. Why?
The researchers made a calculation error. The researchers calculated an exact \(95\)% CI (not an approximate \(95\)% CI). The statistical validity conditions are not met.
The difference is computed as the number of DMFT for coeliacs minus non-coeliacs. True or false?
One of the values for the CI is a negative value, which must be an error, since a negative number of DMFT is impossible. True or false?
We are \(95\)% confidence that the difference between the population means is:

Larger for coeliacs Smaller for coeliacs Between 2.32 higher for non-coeliacs to 2.76 higher for coeliacs. Between 2.76 higher for non-coeliacs to 2.32 higher for coeliacs.

The researchers used an exact \(95\)%CI, which gives very similar answers to using an approximate \(95\)% CI. (The \(68\)--\(95\)--\(99.7\) rule gives approximate multipliers only.)
TRUE. If we take the coeliac mean minus the non-coeliac mean, we would have \(8.39 - 8.17 = 0.22\), which is what is given in the table.
FALSE. The CI is for the difference in the DMFT. The value is not about the number of teeth; it is about the difference in the number of teeth between coeliacs and non-coeliacs. A negative value is fine if we understand what the CI is estimating.
The positive value of \(2.76\) means (as we saw in the first Quick Revision question) that coeliacs have a mean of 2.76 more DMFT.
So the negative value of \(-2.32\) means that non-coeliacs have a mean of \(2.32\) more DMFT.

Free Online Poll Maker

References

Khalaf ME, Akbar A, Alkhubaizi Q, Qudeimat M. Caries among adult patients with controlled celiac disease: A cross-sectional study. Special Care in Dentistry. Wiley Online Library; 2020;40(5):457–63.