Chapter 6 Other uses of Multiple Membership Models

Multiple membership models can be combined with a number of other model types, and they are not restricted to only one level. It is possible to have multiple membership at level 2, but a pure hierarchy at level 3. Multiple membership models can be combined with a three level model to incorporate longitudinal data as well (for example Leroux 2019). They can also be combined with cross-classified models Beretvas (2011) to handle even more complex data structures.

A use I found particularly interesting for multiple membership models was to handle missing data. Hill and Goldstein (1998) proposed using a multiple membership structure to equally weight all possible schools for a student when actual school enrollment was unknown. For students who had a known school membership, they were simply members of one school, with a weight of 1. I found this an interesting approach to missing data, as you are still able to use the student information, though with less school information than those students who have a known membership.

References

Beretvas, S. Natasha. 2011. “Cross-Classified and Multiple-Membership Models.” In Handbook for Advanced Multilevel Analysis, 313–34. Routledge Taylor; Francis Group.
Hill, Peter, and Harvey Goldstein. 1998. “Multilevel Modeling of Educational Data with Cross-Classification and Missing Identification for Units.” Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 23: 117–28.
Leroux, Audrey J. 2019. “Student Mobility in Multilevel Growth Modeling: A Multiple Membership Piecewise Growth Model.” The Journal of Experimental Education 87: 430–48.