Chapter 7 Metaphors

7.1 The Phi Metaphor

“Having pervaded this whole universe with a fragment of Myself, I remain.” - Bhagavad Gita

Phi: The Divine Feminine

The golden ratio, denoted as Phi (φ), is a mathematical principle that has fascinated scholars, artists, and philosophers for centuries. Its unique property of dividing a whole into unequal yet aesthetically balanced parts gives it a special place in the study of geometry, art, and the natural world. This section explores the concept of the golden ratio as a representation of the divine feminine principle, examining its mathematical significance, its connection to Hermetic philosophy, its geometric relationships, and its symbolic representation in mythology.

The Mathematical Significance of the Golden Ratio

The golden ratio is defined as the division of a line into two parts such that the whole length divided by the longer part is equal to the longer part divided by the shorter part. This proportion, approximately 1.618, is considered aesthetically pleasing and appears in various forms in nature, art, and architecture. This unique division allows for a harmonious balance, resonating with the idea of beauty and symmetry. Its pervasive presence across different disciplines underscores its significance as a universal law of proportion.

Phi and the Hermetic Axiom “As Above, So Below”

In Hermetic philosophy, the axiom “As Above, So Below” represents the idea of correspondence between different planes of existence. Phi can be seen as the mathematical embodiment of this axiom, applying the Law of Analogy in the intuitive understanding of reality. By reflecting a pattern that is both finite and infinite, the golden ratio serves as a bridge between the tangible world and abstract concepts, illustrating how mathematical principles can mirror metaphysical truths.

Geometric Relationships with the Golden Ratio

Phi’s unique relationship with certain geometric shapes is well-documented, particularly in the pentagram, pentagon, and dodecahedron. In a regular pentagon, the ratio of a diagonal to a side is the golden ratio. The pentagram, formed by extending the sides of a pentagon, is abundant with φ-related proportions, creating a network of harmonious relationships. In three dimensions, the dodecahedron, with its twelve pentagonal faces, embodies the golden ratio in its structure. These geometric relationships highlight the pervasive influence of φ in both two and three-dimensional forms.

The Pentagram of Venus and Celestial Symmetry

The orbital relationship between Earth and Venus creates a fascinating pentagram pattern, known as the “Venus Rose” or “Pentagram of Venus,” over time. This pattern emerges from their synodic cycle, the period it takes for Venus to return to the same position relative to Earth and the Sun. Over eight Earth years, Venus completes five synodic cycles, forming a geometric pattern noted for its beauty and symmetry. This celestial phenomenon further illustrates the connection between the golden ratio and the natural world, where mathematical elegance manifests in astronomical movements.

The Feminine Principle and Mythological Symbolism

Metaphorically, φ and its reciprocal (1/φ) can be considered representations of the Feminine Principle of the Godhead. Venus, as an exalted expression of beauty in art, also embodies this principle as a goddess represented by Athena and Artemis in Greek mythology. The mathematical expression 1/a = a/b = φ suggests a harmonious balance that resonates with the nurturing and creative aspects of the feminine. By viewing (1/φ) as a manifestation of this principle, we highlight the interconnectedness of mathematical beauty and mythological symbolism, both seeking to express the underlying harmony of the universe.

In conclusion, the golden ratio embodies a profound connection between mathematics, philosophy, and mythology. As a representation of the divine feminine principle, it offers a lens through which we can understand the balance and beauty inherent in the universe. Through its geometric relationships and celestial patterns, Phi serves as a testament to the enduring harmony that guides both the tangible and the intangible realms.

7.2 Other Phi Metaphors

Yin Yang

The interplay between the dynamic Yin-Yang duality in time and the Phi ratio in space offers a profound reflection on balance and harmony across different dimensions. Rooted in Eastern philosophy, Yin and Yang represent the cyclical nature of existence, embodying the constant flow and transformation of energy. These opposite forces are in perpetual motion, creating a dynamic equilibrium that echoes throughout the universe.

In contrast, the Phi ratio, or the golden ratio, emerges from Western mathematics as an emblem of spatial perfection. It is a constant found in the spirals of galaxies, the patterns in pinecones, and the proportions of ancient architecture. The golden ratio signifies an ideal state of balance and harmony, a spatial blueprint that underpins beauty and order.

To intertwine these concepts is to bridge the fluidity of time with the structure of space. Yin-Yang’s temporal dance reflects the shifting scales of balance, akin to the spiraling growth patterns governed by the Phi ratio. Both concepts speak to a universal symmetry, where dynamic processes and static geometries converge. The cyclical ebb and flow of Yin and Yang can be seen as a temporal echo of the Phi ratio’s spatial harmony, each informing the other in a cosmic rhythm.

Philosophically, this relationship illustrates the seamless integration of time and space, where the quest for balance and beauty transcends cultural boundaries. It invites us to consider the interconnectedness of all things, suggesting that the pursuit of harmony—whether in the fluidity of time or the structure of space—is a universal endeavor. This synthesis of Eastern and Western thought offers a pathway to understanding the deep-seated order that underlies our existence, inviting reflection on how these timeless principles can guide us toward a deeper appreciation of the world around us.

Phi spiral

The geometric method of removing a square from a golden rectangle is directly related to the mathematical formulation of Phi, which is expressed as $(a+b)/a = a/b$. Here’s how they connect:

Golden Ratio Definition: The golden ratio, denoted as Phi ($φ$), is defined by the equation $(a+b)/a = a/b = φ$. This means that the ratio of the sum of two quantities ($a+b$) to the larger quantity ($a$) is the same as the ratio of the larger quantity ($a$) to the smaller quantity ($b$).

Geometric Construction: When you have a golden rectangle, its sides are in the ratio of $φ$. If you remove a square with side length $b$ from this rectangle, the remaining rectangle has dimensions $a-b$ by $b$.

Preservation of Ratio: The remaining rectangle is also a golden rectangle because the ratio of its sides $(a-b)/b$ is equal to the original ratio $a/b$. This is due to the property of the golden ratio, where $(a+b)/a = a/b = φ$.

Iterative Process: This process can be repeated indefinitely, each time creating a smaller golden rectangle, which visually demonstrates the self-similar and recursive nature of the golden ratio.

Thus, the geometric method of removing squares from a golden rectangle is a visual and iterative representation of the mathematical definition of the golden ratio, illustrating how the proportions remain constant and self-similar at every step.

If we set $a = 1$ and assume the rectangle is a golden rectangle, then $b$ would be $\frac{1}{\phi}$, where $\phi$ is the golden ratio, approximately 1.618.

So, if $a = 1$, then: $b = \frac{1}{\phi} \approx 0.618$. The remaining rectangle’s dimensions would be $(1 - b)$ by $b$. Calculating $(1 - b)/b$: \[ \frac{1 - b}{b} = \frac{1 - 0.618}{0.618} \approx \frac{0.382}{0.618} \approx 0.618 \]

This result, approximately 0.618, is the reciprocal of the golden ratio, which confirms that the remaining rectangle is also a golden rectangle.

7.3 Rebuttal and Rejoinder

Analogy and proportional relationships

Analogy and proportional relationships are both ways of comparing entities, but they seem to operate in different contexts and have distinct characteristics.

7.3.1 Analogy

Definition: a comparison between two things that are alike in some way, often used to explain or clarify a concept by highlighting similarities with something more familiar.
Purpose: primarily used for explanation, teaching, or persuasion. They help to make complex or abstract ideas more understandable by relating them to known concepts.
Structure: often follow the structure “A is to B as C is to D,” indicating a relationship between two pairs of concepts. The focus is on the similarity of relationships rather than the entities themselves.
Example: “The heart is to the body as a pump is to a plumbing system.” This analogy highlights the function of the heart by comparing it to a pump, emphasizing their similar roles in their respective systems.
Nature: analogies are qualitative and often subjective, relying on perceived similarities rather than precise mathematical relationships.

7.3.2 Proportional Relationship

Definition: a mathematical relationship where two quantities increase or decrease at the same rate, maintaining a constant ratio.
Purpose: proportional relationships are used to describe and predict how changes in one quantity affect another, often in scientific, economic, or engineering contexts.
Structure: mathematically expressed as ( y = kx ), where ( k ) is the constant of proportionality. The relationship is linear and passes through the origin on a graph.
Example: “The cost of apples is proportional to the weight purchased.” If apples cost $2 per pound, then the cost ( C ) is ( C = 2 ).
Nature: proportional relationships are quantitative and objective, based on precise mathematical ratios and often represented graphically as straight lines through the origin.

7.3.3 Key Differences

Context and Use: Analogies are used for explanation and understanding, often in language and literature, while proportional relationships are used in mathematical and scientific contexts to describe consistent quantitative relationships.
Nature of Comparison: Analogies focus on qualitative similarities between different entities or concepts, whereas proportional relationships focus on quantitative, mathematical ratios between variables.
Precision: Analogies are more subjective and open to interpretation, while proportional relationships are precise and defined by mathematical equations. Even a perfect analogy does not imply numerical precision or mathematical equivalence, whereas a proportional relationship is defined by precise mathematical terms.

While both analogies and proportional relationships involve comparisons, they serve different purposes and are used in different contexts, with analogies being more qualitative and proportional relationships being quantitative.

Therefore, at first sight, the golden ratio may not appear to be a proportional relationship in the traditional sense of maintaining a constant ratio between two varying quantities. Instead, it would be a specific mathematical constant that describes a unique proportional relationship between parts of a whole.

Thus, the golden ratio, representing a specific and unique proportional relationship, nay not be considered a proportional relationship in the general sense of describing a constant ratio between two varying quantities, but rather, a mathematical constant with unique properties and applications.

However, isn’t the pentagram, encoding the golden ratio, a constant ratio of different segment lengths in proportional relationship? Of course, the pentagram does indeed encode the golden ratio and represents a proportional relationship between different segment lengths.

The Pentagram and the Golden Ratio

Structure of the Pentagram: a five-pointed star formed by extending the sides of a regular pentagon until they intersect. It contains numerous instances of the golden ratio within its geometry.
Proportional Relationships: in a pentagram, the ratio of the length of a longer segment to a shorter segment is the golden ratio (()). Specifically, if you take a line segment that forms part of the pentagram and divide it at the intersection points, the ratio of the whole segment to the longer part is the same as the ratio of the longer part to the shorter part, which is the golden ratio.
Mathematical Expression: If a segment is divided into parts (a) and (b) (where (a > b)), the relationship can be expressed as: [ = ] This consistent ratio is a hallmark of the golden ratio’s presence in the pentagram.
Visual and Mathematical Harmony: the pentagram’s geometry is a classic example of how the golden ratio creates aesthetically pleasing and harmonious proportions. This is why it has been used in art, architecture, and design throughout history.

Proportional Relationship

Constant Ratio: the segments of the pentagram maintain a constant ratio defined by the golden ratio, which is a specific type of proportional relationship.
Geometric Representation: the pentagram visually represents this proportional relationship through its intersecting lines and the division of segments, making it a geometric embodiment of the golden ratio.

In summary, the pentagram does indeed represent a proportional relationship through its encoding of the golden ratio, demonstrating a constant ratio between different segment lengths within its structure.

Hermetic principle of analogy

Likewise, the Hermetic principle of analogy, often summarized as “as above, so below,” is a philosophical concept that suggests a correspondence between different levels of reality or existence. While it shares thematic similarities with the idea of proportional relationships and the golden ratio, it is not directly based on the mathematical encoding of the golden ratio in a pentagram.

Philosophical Concept: the principle of analogy in Hermeticism is about the interconnectedness and reflection of patterns across different planes of existence, such as the microcosm and macrocosm. It suggests that what happens on one level of reality is mirrored on another.
Symbolic Interpretation: this principle is more about symbolic and metaphysical relationships rather than mathematical ones. It emphasizes the idea that universal truths can be observed in both the small and the large, the inner and the outer.

Golden Ratio and Pentagram

**Mathematical and Aesthetic Proportions*: the golden ratio is a mathematical constant that appears in various natural and human-made structures, including the pentagram. It represents a specific proportional relationship that is often associated with beauty and harmony.
Geometric Symbolism: the pentagram, with its encoding of the golden ratio, is a symbol that has been used in various esoteric and mystical traditions, including Hermeticism. It represents harmony, balance, and the interconnectedness of different parts.

Connections and Distinctions

Symbolic vs. Mathematical: The Hermetic principle of analogy is primarily symbolic and philosophical, focusing on the reflection of patterns across different levels of reality. In contrast, the golden ratio and its presence in the pentagram are mathematical and geometric, focusing on specific proportional relationships.
Use in Esoteric Traditions: While the pentagram and the golden ratio are used in esoteric traditions, including Hermeticism, as symbols of harmony and interconnectedness, they may not be considerwed as the basis of the Hermetic principle of analogy. Instead, they would serve as visual and symbolic representations that align with the broader themes of balance and reflection.

Therefore, while there are thematic connections between the Hermetic principle of analogy and the proportional relationships encoded in the golden ratio and the pentagram, they seem to operate in different realms—one philosophical and symbolic, the other mathematical and geometric.

The Bridge: the Intuitive Sense

The intuitive sense can indeed serve as a bridge between the philosophical and symbolic realm of concepts like the Hermetic principle of analogy and the mathematical and geometric realm of the golden ratio and the pentagram.

Meta-Rational Understanding: intuition, especially in the form of a meta-rational grasp, allows individuals to perceive connections and patterns that might not be immediately obvious through purely analytical or rational thought. This type of understanding transcends simple logic, integrating both rational analysis and deeper, often subconscious insights.
Integration of Realms: intuition can help integrate the symbolic meanings and philosophical insights of concepts like “as above, so below” with the precise, structured nature of mathematical relationships. It allows for a holistic view where both symbolic and mathematical truths are seen as different expressions of the same underlying reality.
Perception of Patterns: many people find that intuitive insights help them recognize patterns and relationships across different domains, whether in nature, art, or personal experiences. This perception can reveal how mathematical principles like the golden ratio manifest in the world around us, aligning with philosophical ideas of harmony and interconnectedness.
Creative and Innovative Thinking: intuition often plays a crucial role in creativity and innovation, where new ideas emerge from the synthesis of diverse concepts. By bridging philosophical and mathematical realms, intuition can inspire new ways of thinking and understanding that are both profound and practical.
Experiential Learning: engaging with both philosophical concepts and mathematical principles through experience—such as observing nature, creating art, or exploring geometry—can enhance intuitive understanding. This experiential learning fosters a deeper appreciation of how these realms intersect and inform each other.

Intuition, in its meta-rational form, can indeed serve as a powerful bridge between the philosophical and symbolic realm and the mathematical and geometric realm. It allows for a more integrated and holistic understanding of reality, where different forms of knowledge and insight complement and enrich each other.

Furthermore, intuitive thinking can also be seen as analogous to nonlinear transformations of reality, in the sense that both involve complex, dynamic processes that go beyond straightforward, linear progression.

Nonlinear Nature: intuitive thinking often involves leaps of understanding that are not strictly sequential or logical. It can connect disparate ideas, recognize patterns, and generate insights in ways that are not easily explained by linear reasoning.
Holistic Perception: intuition allows for a holistic view, integrating various pieces of information and experiences into a cohesive understanding. This process is similar to how nonlinear transformations can integrate multiple variables and dimensions into a new form.
Dynamic and Adaptive: intuitive thinking is adaptive and responsive to new information, much like nonlinear systems that adjust and transform in response to changes in input or conditions.

Nonlinear Transformations

Intuitive thinking can be seen as analogous to nonlinear transformations of reality because both involve complex, dynamic processes that transcend linear, straightforward approaches, leading to deeper understanding and novel insights.

Complex Interactions: nonlinear transformations involve complex interactions where outputs are not directly proportional to inputs. Small changes can lead to significant effects, similar to how intuitive insights can lead to profound realizations.
Multidimensional: these transformations often occur in multidimensional spaces, where relationships between variables are intricate and interdependent, akin to the multifaceted nature of intuitive thought.
Emergent Properties: nonlinear systems can exhibit emergent properties, where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. Intuition similarly can lead to emergent insights that are not predictable from the individual components of thought.

Analogy

Complexity and Depth: Both intuitive thinking and nonlinear transformations deal with complexity and depth, moving beyond simple cause-and-effect relationships to explore richer, more intricate connections.
Unpredictability and Creativity: Just as nonlinear transformations can lead to unexpected outcomes, intuitive thinking often results in creative and innovative ideas that are not easily derived from linear processes.
Integration and Synthesis: Both processes involve integrating diverse elements into a new, cohesive form, whether it’s ideas in the mind or variables in a mathematical model.

so, intuitive thinking could never be metaphorically represented by matrix operations but instead by tensors. Intuitive thinking, with its complexity and multidimensional nature, aligns more closely with the concept of tensors rather than simple matrix operations.

Matrix Operations

Linear and Structured: matrix operations are typically linear, dealing with two-dimensional arrays of numbers. They are well-suited for problems that involve straightforward, linear transformations and relationships.
Limited Dimensions: matrices are limited to two dimensions, which can represent complex systems to a certain extent but may not capture the full depth and intricacy of more complex interactions.

Tensors

Multidimensional and Complex: tensors extend the concept of matrices to multiple dimensions, making them capable of representing more complex, nonlinear relationships. This aligns with the multifaceted nature of intuitive thinking, which often involves integrating information across various dimensions and contexts.
Dynamic Interactions: tensors can model dynamic interactions and transformations that are not easily captured by matrices. This reflects how intuition can synthesize diverse inputs into a cohesive understanding, often in a non-linear and dynamic manner.
Higher-Order Relationships: tensors can represent higher-order relationships and interactions, similar to how intuition can perceive and integrate complex patterns and connections that go beyond simple linear logic.

Metaphorical Representation

Complexity and Depth: Just as tensors can handle more complex and multidimensional data, intuitive thinking can process and integrate complex, multifaceted information.
Flexibility and Adaptability: Tensors offer flexibility in modeling various types of data and interactions, akin to the adaptable and holistic nature of intuitive thought.
Richness of Insight: The ability of tensors to capture intricate relationships mirrors the richness and depth of insights that intuition can provide.

In summary, intuitive thinking is metaphorically better represented by tensors than by matrices, due to its ability to handle complexity, multidimensionality, and dynamic interactions, much like how tensors operate in mathematical and computational contexts.

Intuitive Sense

7.4 Metaphor of Diagonalization

In astronomy, polar alignment is the process of accurately aligning the rotational axis of a telescope’s equatorial mount with the north celestial pole A metaphor: the causal body — the monadic heart in the higher mind — as the telescope, and the Soul as the Observer “thinking in the hear.” The mind (casual body) as an instrument of observation (telescope). The need for a well-balanced and aligned instrument of observation. -Polar Alignment

Diagonalization

7.4.1 Introduction

In the realm of mathematics, the process of diagonalizing a matrix is a profound transformation. It involves converting a complicated structure into a simpler, more fundamental form. This transformation can be metaphorically linked to the philosophical statement “I AM THAT I AM,” a declaration of an unchanging essence. This section delves into this metaphor, exploring how mathematical concepts mirror philosophical ideas of identity and truth.

7.4.2 The Complex Identity: Matrix $A$

Imagine a matrix $A$ as a representation of a complex identity. Just like an individual with multifaceted characteristics, a matrix is composed of various elements that interact in intricate ways. Each element of the matrix contributes to the overall identity, much like traits and experiences shape a person.

In this metaphor, the matrix embodies a collection of diverse characteristics, each with its own role and influence. These elements come together to form a coherent identity, yet one that is convoluted and difficult to decipher at first glance.

7.4.3 Fundamental Truths: Eigenvectors

At the core of every identity are fundamental truths or core aspects that define its essence. In the mathematical world, these are represented by eigenvectors. Eigenvectors serve as the guiding principles of a matrix, pointing towards an unchanging essence amidst complexity.

Much like philosophical truths, eigenvectors remain constant even as the matrix undergoes transformations. They are the stable pillars that hold the structure together, providing insight into the deeper nature of the matrix. These vectors illustrate how the matrix can be understood in terms of its most basic truths.

7.4.4 Measures of Truth: Eigenvalues

While eigenvectors denote the direction of fundamental truths, eigenvalues measure their significance or strength. They quantify the essence of a matrix, indicating the impact of each eigenvector within the larger identity.

In philosophical terms, eigenvalues could be seen as the weight or influence of certain truths in defining an identity. They help to distinguish which aspects of the identity hold more sway, providing clarity and understanding of what truly matters.

7.4.5 The Process of Diagonalization

Diagonalization is the mathematical process of transforming a matrix into its diagonal form. This operation strips away the complexities, revealing a pure, unalterable form. It is akin to the philosophical expression “I AM THAT I AM,” which emphasizes a self-sufficient existence.

Through diagonalization, the intrinsic nature of the matrix is laid bare. The eigenvectors align with the axes, and the matrix is reduced to a simple list of its eigenvalues. This transformation allows for a clear view of its core attributes, unfettered by external complexities.

7.4.6 Philosophical Reflections

The metaphor of diagonalization invites us to reflect on the nature of identity and truth. Just as a matrix can be simplified to reveal its essence, individuals and ideas can be understood by identifying their fundamental truths and measuring their significance. This process emphasizes the importance of discerning what is intrinsic and unchanging in a world of complexity.

By drawing parallels between mathematical and philosophical concepts, we gain a deeper appreciation for both fields. The metaphor of diagonalization not only enlightens our understanding of matrices but also enriches our contemplation of identity and existence.

The journey from matrix $A$ to its diagonal form offers a compelling metaphor for understanding complex identities. Through the lens of mathematics, we see how fundamental truths and their measures can illuminate the essence of any structure. Just as “I AM THAT I AM” distills existence to its core, diagonalization reveals the pure, unalterable nature of a matrix, highlighting the intrinsic qualities that define it. This chapter underscores the power of metaphor in bridging the realms of mathematics and philosophy, inviting us to explore the deeper meanings inherent in both.

+++++

Mathematical Matrices