Designcraft for experiments
Chapter 1 Introduction
Welcome to experimental design. There are two sets of three exercises provided to explore principles for better experiments. This is a simple book to support the practical, at-home learning associated with experimental design. The text ‘Experimental Design for the Life Sciences’ underpins the design principles (Ruxton and Colgrave. 2018).
Life is an experiment. Individually and collectively. We experiment everyday. This is an opportunity to formalize some of those processes and make the learning from experimental design thinking a craft you can apply to all challenges. There are two primary modules to support this process.
Field experiments comprises three outdoor experiments to explore sampling heterogeneous, complex processes in natural systems. The purpose is to provide choice. You need to try each, briefly, as a pilot experiment only. Then, select one to pursue in depth and write up as a research article.
The data experiments describe the opportunity to use design thinking to structure existing data that others have already collected. The same principles for better experiments still apply in how you reuse the data. There are also three examples provided. Select only one and write up as a note.
Both report formats supported by FACETS. It is the first and only open access science journal in Canada.
Part 1. Workflow for pilot and field experiment
- Do all three field experiments in brief, pilot only, try each for a few hours.
- Then, select one of the first three field experiments.
- Do a deeper dive with your choice, i.e. fuller experiment wherein you structure observation by a key variable in the environment. Keep it observational.
- Design the experiment; collect the field data.
- Consider combining data from other students that examined the same system.
- Publish your final field data with meta-data to figshare and also submit to teaching assistant via turnitin.com. Ensure you include the link to the figshare data in the pdf of work you submit to teaching assistant.
- Write up the field experiment you completed for the deeper dive as a research article for the Canadian open science journal Facets.
- Submit field experiment paper to teaching assistant via turnitin.com.
Field experiments gear
|birdwatching||lawn chair or balcony||a good spot to sit and observe birds|
|birdwatching||field guide or smartphone||support identification|
|birdwatching||binoculars, scope, smartphone||facilitate spotting and take pics (not critical)|
|bioblitz||practical shoes||good for thoroughly surveying your identified space|
|bioblitz||smartphone||iNaturalist app (not required but useful)|
|bioblitz||smartphone||take pics of animals|
|bioblitz||net||sweep and capture then release insects (not critical)|
|surveys||practical shoes||walking around your 50m outdoor space|
|surveys||measuring device for transect||tape, rope, phone with digital ruler, anything you can lay or run out for 50m|
|surveys||linear object for quadrat||bamboo, stick, pvc pipe, broom handle cut up, anything that is 0.5m long, preferably make a square|
Part 2. Workflow for the data-design lab report
- Explore each dataset.
- Plan a variable to structure your design and analysis.
- Reuse the data to explore your hypothesis and test your predictions.
- Write a short research ‘note’ format paper suitable for publication in Facets journal.
- Submit paper to teaching assistant via turnitin.com.
Data-design experiments gear
|all three data labs||access to computer or tablet||download dataset, explore data|
|all three data labs||R, Python, or any free stats app||plot data and do stats|
|all three data labs||internet access||to download data and submit note to teaching assistant|
|all three data labs||Google Scholar or Web of Science||check literature on key topics|
|magic||a pack of cards||consider getting a pack to think over process (not critical)|
|diversity||look for photographs online||explore how the data were collected visually|
|human||check out fitbits and trackers||check out watches, fitbit, trackers and explore limitations (not critical)|
Lortie, CJ (2021): Designcraft for experiments. figshare. Book. https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.14944398.v2
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.